As many of you know, the topic of Derek Jeter vs David Wright became a point of contention on this blog earlier in the year. Since today is a particularly slow day at the office, I thought it might be a good time to examine the respecitve seasons of each player thus far.
Raw Numbers:
Batting Average: Jeter .321, Wright .318
RBI: Wright 48, Jeter 43
OBP: Wright .409, Jeter .398
OPS: Wright .864, Jeter .855
HR: Jeter 11, Wright 6
Hits: Jeter 123, Wright 115
Runs: Jeter 63, Wright 62
BB/SO: Jeter 46/51, Wright 55/94
Steals (Caught): Wright 21(8), Jeter 18 (4)
RISP Avg: Wright .339, Jeter .289
2-out RISP: Jeter .306, Wright .235
So what can we make of the above numbers? Certainly there are outside factors at play. The two play in different leagues, ballparks, and lineups. They face different pitchers (with the exception of interleague).
So lets look at their interleague numbers:
Wright- .213, 13 hits, 5 runs, 0 HR, 6 RBI, .525 OPS
Jeter- .390, 23 hits, 15 runs, 3 Hr, 6 RBI, 1.048 OPS
Now in interleague play, the Mets and the rest of the NL East played the Yankees and the rest of the AL East. Based on these numbers, Jeter had a much better time against the teams that Wright usually faces. Vice-versa, not so much. Let’s look at the head to head, Yankees vs Mets
Jeter vs Mets- .533, 8 hits, 5 runs, 1 Hr, 4 RBI, 1.411 OPS
Wright vs Yankees- .217, 5 hits, 2 runs, 0 HR, 1 RBI, .584 OPS.
So, in this head-to-head matchup, Jeter has a clear edge.
Again, what can we make of these numbers? First, I think reports of Jeter’s demise have been greatly exaggerated. Second, Wright is clearly working with a handicapped lineup. Third, an injured Alex Rodriguez, who may need additional surgery is clearly out slugging Wright, and his numbers in half as many at-bats are on pace to dwarf Wright’s by season’s end. Again, the respective lineups and ballparks can be sighted as reasons. One could argue that Wright would be successful in the HR friendly new Yankee Stadium as opposed to the pitcher’s park Citi Field. However, the numbers of Jeter and A-Rod vs the NL suggest that they would be putting up superior numbers to Wright if they faced the inferior NL pitching on a regular basis. Not to continue to harp on A-Rod, but his road numbers beat Wright’s as well with the exception of average.
As for the argument about Wright’s lineup (or lack thereof) I would point to Ryan Zimmerman. With the awful Nationals surrounding him, he has put up similar numbers to Wright, and his slugging numbers are much higher (17 HR and 60 RBI).
So what do we make of these numbers? Thoughts?