As the Yankees closed out Game 6 last night with a victory over the Angels, and headed to their first World Series since 2003, I went over to Facebook to enjoy the pennant win with other Yankee fans.
Many of the comments I found were expected; die-hards expressing excitement and relief, bandwagon-jumpers crowing, and Phillies fans throwing down the gauntlet. However, one trend began to emerge which I must admit caught me a bit off-guard. Friends who are Met fans began declaring their intention to support….the Phillies?
Now I can understand Met fans finding this series a bit distasteful. It’s your main divisional rival against the team you fight for the hearts of the city faithful. I know I wouldn’t like it if the Red Sox played the Mets in the World Series. Still, if a rematch of the 1986 Series were to occur, the idea of rooting for Boston would not cross my mind. Not for a second.
The immediate support for the Phillies, and the adamant “eff you” attitude displayed toward any Yankee fan who had the temerity to question this decision, was startling. The asinine comparisons to Sophie’s Choice, are even worse. Sure Met fans, deciding who to cheer for in a world series between two teams you dont like is JUST like a woman choosing which child will live and which will die in a concentration camp during the Holocaust. Nice job, very rational. Even if this was done tounge-in-cheek, it is beyond stupid to compare the two. Despite the less-serious implications of the phrase “Sophie’s Choice” as it has come to be used in the common parlance, this is a serious misapplication of the term.
I am struggling to figure a reason why, beyond spite, bitterness, and envy, an New Yorker would back the Phillies. So lets outline some possibilities:
1) You like NL Baseball- So you are a Met fan first, but after that you are a fan of the game “the way it was meant to be played”. You enjoy the inferior product the NL offers up as a whole, and think the DH is a travesty. If it comes down to it, the NL representative should be the team to win it all.
2) You would rather hear from Phillies fans than Met fans-You know more Yankees fans. You live near them, you work with them, you see them around the city. We will gloat and strut after winning the World Series, and you will have to watch it happen. We will cast off our recent post season failures, and reassume our place on top of the mountain. This will bother you to no end. You will decide to root for a team who repeatedly denies you a spot in the playoffs, who wins where you fail, whose fans say worse things to you than any Yankee fan. This will be your team of choice. Not a team whose fans most likely make up many of your friends and family, no, a team whose city and fans laugh at you and your mediocrity.
3) You don’t like the Yankees way of operating- Oh wait, the Mets spend like crazy too, and would have done more if they hadn’t been rocked by the Madoff scheme. Never mind then, thats just a littler pot calling a bigger kettle black.
But as I continued to think on the subject, I realized something….good. You are rooting for the Phillies? Good. We never counted on the support of Met fans, and we won’t count on it now. We will gladly throw the support of a karma-striken, sad-sack, bitter and demoralized group of fans behind Philadelphia. I am not sure we would even want to be associated with a bunch of fans who create a baseless and unwarranted air of superiority around themselves and their choke-job of a team, fans who can’t be happy for their friends. We’d be pulling for you against the Red Sox, but maybe you don’t have that kind of rivalry with Philly. You haven’t given us a chance to see if its true, but I wager the Yankee fans in this city would pull for the Mets vs anyone AL. Maybe if one day they stop gagging away their playoff chances we will see. But for now, enjoy watching the Phillies lose, and when they do, show Phillie fans how to deal with failure. It’s what you are good at….
PS – To Met fans on our side I say “Welcome aboard”, there’s plenty of room on the bandwagon and we’re happy to have fellow New Yorkers.